NRCGT penalty

In July 2016 I found out that my client (who lives in Indonesia) had sold a UK buy to let property in October 2015.  I immediately sent in a NRCGT return online.  He now has a penalty notice for £1,300 for not sending in the return within 30 days of the conveyance.  The gain returned is £204.  The fine seems to me to be disproportionate and unjust because he, not unreasonably, expected to return the details of the gain on his 2016 tax return in the normal way.  With hindsight I can see that I should have flagged this up just because he is a non resident landlord in case he happened to want to sell a property.  I am looking for reasonable excuses to appeal this and pointed out that knowing he is non resident his solicitor should have warned him about the 30 days.  The solicitor is well respected locally and has replied candidly that he knew nothing about the 30 day time limit and to be fair neither did I at the start of the 2015-16 tax year.  I know that not knowing the rules is no excuse but this seems so unfair.  If professionals don’t know about new online reporting rules how can the tax payer in Indonesia (where communications are not the best) be expected to know?  Is there any way to challenge this and is anyone else in the same boat?

Parents Reply
  • Anonymous
    Anonymous over 1 year ago in reply to Anonymous

    Do I have to attend a hearing?

    HM Courts & Tribunals Service provide guidance (leaflets T242, T243 and T244 – use the link to court and tribunal forms) on what happens after you make your appeal and on what happens at a hearing. We recommend that you read this in addition to our guidance below.

    At the level of the First-tier Tribunal, there are different ways in which your case can be handled depending on the facts, such as what it is you are appealing about and how complex your case is.

    Some cases are usually dealt with on paper. This means that the tribunal will just review papers submitted by HMRC and by you, and make their decision from those.

    If your case is to be dealt with in this way, it is important that your papers are neat and tidy so that the tribunal can follow them. Read the section ‘How do I prepare my case?’, which guides you through organising your papers. If you are told your case will be dealt with on paper, but you would prefer to have a hearing, you can request one.

    If you have any special needs, which they might need to cater for at the hearing, for example, if you have a disability, you should tell the tribunal in advance.